Top Ten Considerations for Selecting Nonprofit Board Members (ALIGN)

Attracting and recruiting the right board members is vital to the success and sustainability of a human service agency. The right mix of skills, experience, and perspectives strengthens governance, enhances strategic decision-making, and ensures the organization stays mission-focused while adapting to changing community needs.

Back

Effective board members bring valuable networks, credibility, and resources that can open doors to new partnerships and funding opportunities. They also provide critical oversight and accountability, helping to maintain transparency, ethical standards, and trust with stakeholders. Ultimately, a strong and diverse board empowers the agency to deliver greater impact and long-term stability for the communities it serves. Here are the top ten considerations to keep in mind when selecting nonprofit board members:

1. Skills and Expertise

  • Ensure that the board members have diverse skills and experience that align with the nonprofit’s mission and strategic goals. These may include financial expertise, legal knowledge, fundraising, marketing, program management, or industry-specific knowledge.

2. Commitment to the Mission

  • Board members should be passionate about the nonprofit’s mission and values. Their personal alignment with the organization’s purpose is crucial for long-term dedication and informed decision-making.

3. Diversity and Representation

  • A well-rounded board should reflect a broad range of perspectives, including diversity of race, ethnicity, gender, age, geographic location, and professional background. Diversity can help the board make more informed and inclusive decisions.

4. Time and Availability

  • Board members must be able to dedicate the time and energy needed to attend meetings, participate in committees, and support fundraising efforts. It’s essential to assess whether potential members can consistently meet these time requirements.

5. Fundraising Capacity

  • Nonprofits often rely on board members to help with fundraising and donor relations. Look for members with strong networks, credibility, and an ability to open doors for potential donors or partners.

6. Governance Experience

  • Board members should have a solid understanding of nonprofit governance, including fiduciary duties, compliance, and legal responsibilities. Prior experience on a nonprofit board or in a leadership role is highly beneficial.

7. Team Dynamics and Collaboration

  • Evaluate how well potential members will work with others on the board. Board members should be able to collaborate effectively, respect differing opinions, and contribute to a positive, productive team dynamic.

8. Leadership and Influence

  • Strong leaders bring strategic thinking and influence. Look for individuals who have demonstrated leadership within their professional or community roles, as they can guide the organization toward achieving its long-term goals.

9. Cultural Fit and Passion

  • In addition to skills and expertise, potential board members should fit with the organization’s culture. They should demonstrate a shared passion for the cause and be willing to advocate for the nonprofit’s vision.

10. Conflict of Interest

  • Ensure that potential members do not have conflicts of interest that could affect their objectivity and commitment to the nonprofit. They should be transparent about any potential conflicts and be willing to recuse themselves when necessary.

By carefully considering these factors, a nonprofit can build a diverse, skilled, and committed board that will effectively guide the organization toward success.

Published on

November 13, 2025